The risks that safety advocates are raising are not imaginary. Alignment failures, systems that pursue objectives their designers did not intend, are a genuine engineering problem. The concentration of AI development in a handful of companies across two countries creates power asymmetries with real implications for accountability. The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Volker Türk, was direct: AI "is used to watch us, judge us, and control us" in ways that people often cannot challenge. Surveillance at scale, predictive policing, algorithmic decision-making in welfare and immigration these are not hypothetical risks. They are operational realities in systems already running.